The Miss Monticello Pageant was held for the first time in 1996. Since that time the pageant has grown each year by leaps and bounds. The first Miss Monticello Oustanding Teen was chosen in 1998, the first Miss Wayne County Area was chosen in 2005 and Miss Historic Mill Spring in 2018. In this section, you will find a listing of the winners each year, as well as the awards they received at their respective state and national competitions.
Miss Monticello Title Holders

Are You Next?!
To find out more about how to become the next Miss Monticello, click here

- 2025: Karrington True, Lexington

-
-
-
-
2024: Adysin Donk, Hebron

-
2023: Chapel Tinius,
Bowling Green
2nd Runner-Up
Preliminary Talent Award
1st Runner-Up Quality of Life
- Miss Kentucky 2024
Bowling Green
2nd Runner-Up
Preliminary Talent Award
1st Runner-Up Quality of Life
- Miss Kentucky 2024

-
2022: Molly Sullivan, Campbellsville
Non-Finalist Interview Award

-
2020-2021: Chapel Tinius, Bowling Green
1st Runner-up
Preliminary On-Stage Interview Winner
Quality of Life Finalist
Newcomer Award - America's Sweetheart - 3rd Runner Up
-
Miss Kentucky 2024

-
2019: Carolina Ford, Bowling Green
Top 8 Finalist
Runway Model Award
.
Top 8 Finalist
Runway Model Award
.jpg)
-
2018: Yulia Perevozchikova, Morehead
4th Runner Up
Preliminary Talent Award
Newcomer Award
Academic Award
4th Runner Up
Preliminary Talent Award
Newcomer Award
Academic Award
.jpg)
-
2017:Susanna White, Lexington
Preliminary Talent Award
Top 11 Finalist
Preliminary Talent Award
Top 11 Finalist

-
2016: Dakoda Trenary, Owenton
Top 11 Finalist
Top 11 Finalist

-
2015: Madison McCowan, London
Top 13 Finalist
Top 13 Finalist

-
2014: Kiley Brennan Shuffett, Greensburg
Top 13 Finalist
Top 13 Finalist

-
2013: Miranda Buchanan, Frankfort

-
2012: Annie Franklin, Winchester
Preliminary Swimsuit Winner
3rd Runner Up
.
Preliminary Swimsuit Winner
3rd Runner Up

-
2011:Shaina Esser, Louisville
Top 12 Finalist
Top 12 Finalist

-
2010: Ann-Blair Thornton, Bowling Green
1st Runner Up
National Sweetheart 1st Runner Up
Preliminary Evening Wear Winner at National SweetHeart
MISS KENTUCKY 2011
1st Runner Up
National Sweetheart 1st Runner Up
Preliminary Evening Wear Winner at National SweetHeart
MISS KENTUCKY 2011
.

-
2009: Kelly Casey, Nicholasville
Top 10 Finalist
Top 10 Finalist

-
2008 Hannah Herald, Lexington
.

-
2007 Kaitlynne Postel, Lexington
MISS KENTUCKY 2007
.
MISS KENTUCKY 2007
.jpg)
-
2006: Anne Clair Correll, Somerset
Preliminary Talent Winner
Top 10 Finalist
Preliminary Talent Winner
Top 10 Finalist

-
2005: Sarah Billiter, Pikeville
Top 10 Finalist
.
Top 10 Finalist

-
2004: Lindsay Block, Bardstown
Top 10 Finalist
.
Top 10 Finalist

-
2003 MacKenzie Mayes, London
Preliminary Swimsuit Winner
Community Service Winner /
Quality of Life Winner
-
MISS KENTUCKY 2003
Miss America NonFinalist Talent
1st Runner Up - Quality of Life
Preliminary Swimsuit Winner
Community Service Winner /
Quality of Life Winner
Miss America NonFinalist Talent
1st Runner Up - Quality of Life

-
2002: Bethany Moore, Monticello
Preliminary Swimsuit Winner
3rd Runner-Up
Preliminary Swimsuit Winner
3rd Runner-Up

-
2001: Kari Lee Rustay, Nicholasville

- 2000: MacKenzie Mayes, London
Community Service Winner
1st Runner-Up
- NATIONAL SWEETHEART WINNER
Preliminary Swimsuit Winner at National Sweetheart
Preliminary Evening Wear Winner at National Sweetheart
Community Service Winner
1st Runner-Up
Preliminary Swimsuit Winner at National Sweetheart
Preliminary Evening Wear Winner at National Sweetheart

-
1999: Tonya Ramsey, Monticello
Non-finalist Interview Winner
Non-finalist Interview Winner

-
1998: Beth Sweeney, Liberty
Top 10 Finalist
Top 10 Finalist

-
1997: Robin Litteral, Corbin
Community Service Winner
Top 10 Finalist
-
1997: Robin Litteral, Corbin
Community Service Winner
Top 10 Finalist
Community Service Winner
Top 10 Finalist

-
1996: Chera-Lyn Cook, London
Preliminary Talent Winner
Top 10 Finalist
MISS KENTUCKY 1998
.
Preliminary Talent Winner
Top 10 Finalist
MISS KENTUCKY 1998
Miss Wayne County Area Title Holders

- 2025: Turner Reynolds, Versailles

-
2024: Molly Sullivan, Campbellsville
2nd Runner-Up
Quality of Life 1st Runner Up
AHA Overall Fundraiser
Marketing Award

-
2023: Karrington True, Milton
Top 12 Finalist
Quality of Life Finalist
Top 12 Finalist
Quality of Life Finalist

-
2022: Jazzlin Hamilton, Louisville
3rd Runner-Up
Preliminary On-Stage Interview Award
.jpg)
-
2020: Makayela Banks, Somerset

-
2019: Karrington True, Milton
Image Runway Model Award
Image Runway Model Award
.jpg)
-
2017: Charlee Shaefer, Maysville
Preliminary Talent Award
Non-Finalist Talent Award
Preliminary Talent Award
Non-Finalist Talent Award
.jpg)
-
2016: Molly Matney, Edmonton
Top 11 Finalist
MISS KENTUCKY 2017
Top 11 Finalist
MISS KENTUCKY 2017

-
2011: Jefra Bland, Campbellsville
2nd Runner Up
2nd Runner Up

-
2010: Elizabeth Ellis,
Campbellsville
Campbellsville

-
2008: Elizabeth Hood, Corbin
Preliminary Swimsuit Winner
Preliminary Swimsuit Winner

-
2007: Katisha Pickrell, Monticello

-
2006: Ean Whitney Cox,
Lancaster
Lancaster

-
2005: Rebecca Dishman, Monticello
Join the legacy
Find out more
Miss Historic Mill Springs Title Holder
Miss Monticello's Oustanding Teen Title Holders

Are You Next?!
To find out more about how to become the next Miss Monticello's Outstand Teen, click here

- 2025: Ella Mattingly, Winchester

-
2024: Anyslee Ellis, Harrodsburg
Spirit of Miss Kentucky's Teen Award

-
2023: Aileen Conner,
Top 8 Finalist
4th Runner-Up
Preliminary Talent Award
Newcomer Award
Top 8 Finalist
4th Runner-Up
Preliminary Talent Award
Newcomer Award

-
2022: Emma Hackworth, Winchester
4th Runner-Up
1st Runner-Up Quality of Life
4th Runner-Up
1st Runner-Up Quality of Life

-
2020: Brooklyn Roller, Bardstown
1st Runner Up -Quality of Life
Top 11 Finalist
1st Runner Up -Quality of Life
Top 11 Finalist

-
2019: Makayla King, Winchester
1st Runner Up
1st Runner Up - Quality of Life
-
2019: Makayla King, Winchester
1st Runner Up
1st Runner Up - Quality of Life

-
2018: Reagan Earlywine, Paris
2nd Runner Up
Talent Preliminary Award
2nd Runner Up
Talent Preliminary Award

-
2017: Turner Reynolds, Versailles
Preliminary Evening Wear Award
Top 11 Finalist
Preliminary Evening Wear Award
Top 11 Finalist

-
2016: Reagan Earlywine, Paris
.

-
2015: Chapel Tinius, Bowling Green
4th Runner-Up
Preliminary Talent Award
Laura Hancock Instrumental Talent Award
Overall Talent Winner
- MISS KENTUCKY'S OUTSTANDING TEEN 2016
4th Runner-Up
Preliminary Talent Award
Laura Hancock Instrumental Talent Award
Overall Talent Winner
.jpg)
-
2014: Makayela Banks, Somerset

-
2013: Laura Hancock, Somerset
Preliminary Talent Award
Preliminary Fitness Award
First runner-up Quality of Life
- MISS KENTUCKY'S OUTSTANDING TEEN
Preliminary Talent Award
Preliminary Fitness Award
First runner-up Quality of Life

2012: Abigail Stanley, Grayson

-
2011: Kathryn Robinson, Russell
Top 12 Finalist
Top 12 Finalist

-
2010: Aleigh Oney, Grayson
1st Runner Up
Community Service Award
1st Runner Up
Community Service Award

-
2009: Emily Eicher, Monticello
Nonfinalist Talent Award
Nonfinalist Talent Award

-
2008: Katie Himes, Cynthiana

-
2007: Kayla Allen, Monticello

-
2006: Emily Eicher, Monticello
Nonfinalist Talent Award
Nonfinalist Talent Award

-
2005: Leslie Dobbs, Monticello

-
2004: Katisha Pickrell, Monticello
Top 10 Finalist
Top 10 Finalist

-
2003: Natalie Denney, Monticello
- 2003: Natalie Denney, Monticello
.jpg)
-
2002: India Hammond, Monticello

-
2001: Natalie Brown, Monticello
1st Runner Up
1st Runner Up

-
2000: Rebecca Dishman, Monticello

-
1999: Jennifer Lewis, Monticello

-
1998: Bethany Moore, Monticello
Join the legacy
Find out more
Miss Wayne County Area Oustanding Teen Title Holders

2024: Lacy Parnell, Monticello
Non-Finalist Talent Award
-
2020 & 2021: Anneli White, Shelbyville
Quality of Life Winner
Top 11 Finalist
Quality of Life Winner
Top 11 Finalist

-
2018: Joanna Clark, Lexington
Preliminary Gown Winner
Quality of Life Award
Laura Hancock Instrumentalist Award
-
MISS KENTUCKY'S OUTSTANDING TEEN
Preliminary Gown Winner
Quality of Life Award
Laura Hancock Instrumentalist Award

-
2017: Alley Alred, Harlan
Top 11 Finalist
Top 11 Finalist

-
2015: Callie Halsey, Georgetown

-
2014: Molly Dalton, Monticello
Non-Finalist Talent Award
Laura Hancock Instrumental Talent Award
Community Service Award
Non-Finalist Talent Award
Laura Hancock Instrumental Talent Award
Community Service Award

-
2013: Talia Horn, Harrodsburg
Top 12 Finalist
Top 12 Finalist
